Mayor Zohran Mamdani announced on Friday, Nov. 13, that 73 percent of New York City public school classes now meet the caps set by the state's class size law. That share sits three points above the 70 percent benchmark Albany set for this school year. Chancellor Kamar Samuels marked the moment at M.S. 582 in Brooklyn, calling it a "huge, huge step forward" for the system. "Simply put: More attention for our kids, more one-on-one time from their teachers," Samuels said during the visit.

The figure clears the bar, but it rests on a change in how the city counts its classrooms. For the first time, officials included elementary "cluster" classes such as science, art, music and physical education, which are taught outside a student's homeroom, along with middle and high school "exam prep" courses. Without the cluster classes, 69.5 percent of classes would have met the caps, half a point under the legal threshold for the year.

Officials did not define the exam prep courses or say how many of them met the limits. Cluster classes include physical education, which the law caps at 40 students rather than the 20 to 25 students that govern most regular classrooms.

The rules behind those numbers were written in Albany, where the class size mandate was signed into law in 2022 and placed in the section of state Education Law governing Contracts for Excellence. Its requirements reach only a city school district in a city of one million or more people, which in New York means the five boroughs alone. The law caps kindergarten through third grade at 20 students, fourth through eighth grade at 23, high school at 25, and physical education and performing groups at 40.

The schedule the city is now measured against was rewritten in June. Senator John Liu of Queens, who championed the original law, sponsored the amendment with Senator Joseph Addabbo Jr. as a co-sponsor, and it passed the Senate 60 to 0 on Thursday, June 4. Gov. Kathy Hochul signed it on Friday, June 26, as Chapter 155 of the Laws of 2026. The new text keeps the first three years at 20 percentage points each, then adds 10 points a year for four more years, pushing full class size compliance from 2028 to September 2030.

Under that schedule the city needed 60 percent last year and needs 70 percent this year, before climbing to 80 percent in 2027-28, 90 percent the year after and 100 percent in 2029-30. The original timeline would have demanded 80 percent this fall, a target the Education Department had said it was unprepared to meet. Mamdani lobbied for the extension as the city faced a multibillion-dollar budget gap, and in May he said, "We have asked Albany to extend the deadline to meet this mandate." Hochul said the change would give the city "more breathing room to roll out the cost of it."

The price tag has moved all year, starting in February, when Mamdani's preliminary budget included $543 million in anticipation of hiring about 6,000 teachers. His executive budget in May carried $122 million to hire 1,000 teachers, alongside $1.5 billion in new capital funding for classroom space. Michael Mulgrew, president of the United Federation of Teachers, framed the union's support for the delay as a bet on that construction.

"If giving this new administration two more years gets us a partner committed to building the necessary seats, then it is the fastest way to turn the law into reality," Mulgrew said in a statement in June.

The city also changed how it handles classes that miss the caps, and officials said they granted no exemptions this year, down from about 10,000 the year before. Teachers whose classes had been excused can instead receive bonuses of up to $8,500 under the city's agreement with the UFT, rising to as much as $9,500 in 2027-28, with recipients determined each November. Principals are eligible for raises of up to $10,000 for reaching compliance, though Samuels did not say how many of them will qualify.

On hiring, city officials credited a $244 million investment last spring that helped schools add about 1,900 teachers to shrink classes, after roughly $400 million paid for about 3,700 hires the year before. Even so, the overall teacher headcount fell slightly, from about 69,900 to 69,400, which still leaves the system roughly 5,000 teachers ahead of where it stood two years ago.

Enrollment, meanwhile, has kept falling across the city's public school system for more than a decade. The city did not release current-year enrollment figures on Friday, although its own projections anticipated a drop of about 20,000 students this year. Over a longer stretch, a report from City Comptroller Mark Levine found that K-12 enrollment fell by 187,000 students between 2013-14 and 2025-26.

Thirty-one of the city's 32 geographic districts improved over last year's numbers. The exception was Brooklyn's District 13, which dropped from 78 percent of classes under the caps last year to 59 percent this year, and the Education Department did not explain the decline. District 32 in Bushwick led the city at 92 percent, while District 26 in northeast Queens sat at the bottom with 56 percent.

The sharpest split ran along income lines rather than borough lines, with a gap of 33 percentage points between the two ends of the scale. At the city's poorest schools, an average of 90 percent of classes were under the caps, compared with 57 percent at the wealthiest schools. City officials say nearly 500 schools still lack the space to bring every class within the limits.

Next year leaves the city far less room, because reaching 80 percent means moving roughly seven more of every hundred classes under the caps. The cluster classes and exam prep courses that lifted this year's figure are already in the count, so every remaining point has to come from new teachers, new rooms or fewer students.

At M.S. 582, principal Jeffrey Merced credited staffing above everything else the school had tried. "What really helped us was the manpower," he said. He also raised a worry about what comes next, since the Education Department is paying for the new hires now. Merced expects those salaries to come out of his own school's budget one day.

That question will eventually land back in Albany, where the mandate, its timeline and much of its funding are all decided. The class size law is a state statute, the Legislature sets its schedule, and its cost is entangled with the state aid that flows to the city each year. Hochul has already signaled she wants more say over education policy, renewing her push earlier this month for governor control of the State Education Department as she criticized the Regents exam phaseout.

The next state budget will take shape while the city works toward that 80 percent bar for the 2027-28 school year. For families outside the five boroughs, the law sets no caps on their own districts. The city's annual report is still the most detailed public accounting anywhere in the state of what smaller classes cost, how many teachers they take and which schools get them first.

The next checkpoint arrives a year from now, when the city must show that four in five classes meet the limits. Leonie Haimson, executive director of the parent advocacy group Class Size Matters, set the terms for that test back in June. "Let's see the city's class size plan to confirm it's not all smoke and mirrors," she said in a statement.